"A quirky niche book that descends into obscure, even humdrum areas and makes them interesting. In the right hands, such a book can be a pleasure. This is the case with How to Plan a Crusade."
– The New York Times Book Review
"By concentrating on the ‘prosaic methods’ of crusading rather than on the drama of the campaigns, as historians have traditionally done, Crusades expert Tyerman manages to demythologize the process. Tyerman provides a compelling, vivid sense of a lively, pragmatic, driven, and highly organized society. A fresh way to envision the Medieval era."
– Kirkus Reviews
"His deeply researched study is dedicated to exploring the relationship between human reason and religious war in all its aspects—justification, propaganda, recruitment, finance, logistics—to show us how 'reason made religious war possible.'"
– The London Review of Books
"Intriguing. Recommended for scholars and medieval history aficionados."
– Library Journal
"Serious and scholarly, the synthesis of decades of work on difficult, fragmented sources. An impressive and lively book, laced with wry asides and enough surprising details to pique the general reader."
– Jessie Childs, The Guardian
"Tyerman explores the role of reason in medieval wars in this must-read book for history buffs."
"Mining details on logistics 800 years ago is Tyerman's forte, and he throws them on to the page like chaff from a trebuchet. It is comprehensive, laying down a great skein of fact where there was only supposition (much of it false). And, as the West gears up for the crusade against Islamic State, it is horribly timely."
– The Times (London)
"An impressive synthesis of a complicated subject, presented in elegant, readable prose. Not many historians could have done it."
– The Spectator (UK)
"Fascinating not just for what it has to tell us about the Crusades, but for the mirror it holds up to today's religious extremism."
– Tom Holland, The Mail on Sunday (UK)
"A real achievement. Tyerman is a virtuoso with the English language. Filled to the brim with rich descriptions of the intricate planning and preparations that Europeans conducted before their Crusades. There are few scholars today who could match [Tyerman’s] breadth of knowledge regarding the Crusades. Tyerman energetically (and rightly) argues that medieval people were just as rational as modern people."
– The New Criterion